AllegationSexual misconduct

Barre officer resigns after allegations of sexual relationship with woman he arrested

A Barre, Vermont police officer resigned after allegations he had a sexual relationship with a woman he arrested while her criminal case was pending, and prosecutors declined to charge him.

Barre Officer Matthew Frey resigned on Nov. 13 following allegations that he had a sexual relationship with a woman he arrested while her criminal case was pending, VTDigger reported, citing a story first published in The Bridge. The city manager said the city had completed the administrative portion of its investigation. According to an Oct. 23 letter from Orange County State's Attorney Colin Seaman, Frey exchanged messages with the woman and requested and received partially nude photographs, and on Sept. 13 allegedly went to her home and had a sexual encounter with her. The woman filed a complaint on Oct. 1, saying she felt coerced. Frey was placed on paid leave Oct. 5. Washington County prosecutors dismissed about 50 cases involving him over credibility concerns. Vermont State Police investigated, and prosecutors declined to bring criminal charges.

Why it matters

The allegations led prosecutors to issue a Brady-Giglio letter and dismiss about 50 criminal cases involving the officer, with more under review. Prosecutors declined to bring criminal charges against him.

Allegation: An unproven claim, including claims in a lawsuit or complaint. No court or oversight body has found it true. Researched with AI assistance from the sources listed here and reviewed under our methodology.